Unveiling the Prejudices of Fatphobia: A Critical Look at the Documentary ‘What We Don’t Talk About When We Talk About Fat’

Addressing Misconceptions: Challenging Assumptions about Fat

The term ‘fatphobia’ can evoke mixed reactions, with some individuals choosing euphemisms over direct language when discussing weight-related issues. However, it is essential to question the assumption that being fat is solely a matter of choice or always indicative of poor health. Moreover, even if these assumptions were true, they would not justify treating individuals disrespectfully. By exploring these misconceptions, the documentary could have delved into the multifaceted nature of fatphobia, considering factors such as geography, capitalism, and cultural variations.

Limited Exploration: A Narrow Focus on Discrimination

While the documentary primarily focuses on the discrimination faced by fat individuals, it misses opportunities to showcase the celebration of fat bodies in other cultures. Aubrey Gordon, the central figure in the film, is charismatic and engaging, but the documentary fails to highlight thriving counter-trends or provide a broader cultural context. Consequently, viewers are left with an incomplete understanding of the issue, and the film becomes more of a platform for Aubrey’s personal journey rather than a comprehensive exploration of fatphobia.

Challenging Shame and Stereotypes: Empowering Fat Individuals

The documentary effectively highlights the damaging effects of shame and stereotypes on fat individuals. Aubrey shares her personal experiences, including being subjected to Weight Watchers at a young age and enduring feelings of fear and shame around food. This segment of the film resonates with many viewers who have faced similar treatment, encouraging them to recognize that they did not deserve such mistreatment. By shedding light on the detrimental impact of shame, the film effectively challenges the misguided belief that it can serve as a motivator.

Limited Impact: Narrow Scope for Societal Change

The documentary’s aim is to prompt the general public to examine their prejudices, but it is unlikely to reach those who most need this wake-up call. While it successfully serves as a portrait of Aubrey Gordon at a pivotal moment in her life, its impact on dismantling systemic fatphobia is limited. It primarily focuses on addressing internalized prejudices and fostering self-confidence among fat individuals, which is valuable but fails to provide concrete tools for societal change.

Conclusion: A Partial Exploration of Fatphobia

‘What We Don’t Talk About When We Talk About Fat’ is a commendable effort in shedding light on fatphobia and challenging societal prejudices. However, the documentary falls short in providing a comprehensive exploration of the topic. By focusing primarily on the discrimination faced by fat individuals and neglecting other dimensions of fatphobia, it misses opportunities to create a more nuanced understanding of the issue. Nevertheless, the film’s portrayal of Aubrey Gordon’s personal journey and its impact on challenging internalized prejudices contribute to its overall significance.